Form of Government in Countries around the World: Classification Problems and their Possible Solutions

The main purpose of the paper is to develop a unified classification of the states of the world according to the form of government. The author considers the existing approaches, and the classification of the world states in the form of government in the theory and practice of state-building.

Further, the author gives examples of states whose forms of government cannot be classified within the framework of traditional approaches. To solve this problem of classification, the author proposes, in addition to the typical (traditional) forms of government — monarchy and republic, to allocate atypical forms of government — a monarchy with a republican element and a republic with a monarchical element, and within the republican form of government, in addition to the traditional (classical) varieties — presidential, parliamentary and semi-presidential republics. It is proposed to allocate non-traditional (non-classical) varieties — hybrid, superpresidential, socialist and Islamic. In addition, the author distinguishes the mixed republic in two varieties (semipresidential and semi-parliamentary republics) as a kind of watershed between traditional and non-traditional varieties of the republican form of government. Within the framework of the paper, the author also touches upon the question of correlation of the categories «form of government», «state and political regime», concluding that they are independent but interrelated categories. In conclusion, the author summarizes the findings of the study and, for clarity, offers a scheme of his own approach to the classification of the States of the world in the form of government.

1. Avdeev D.A. Respublikanskaya forma pravleniya: problemy klassifikatsii i identifikatsii [Republican government: problems of classification and identification]. Sovremennoe pravo [Modern law]. 2011. No. 4. Pp. 12—14.

2. Avdeev D.A. Forma pravleniya v Rossii (kratkiy konstitutsionnyy ocherk) [Form of government in Russia (short constitutional essay)]. Tyumen, 2015. 244 p.

3. Avtonomov A.S. Konstitutsionnoe (gosudarstvennoe) pravo zarubezhnykh stran : uchebnik [Constitutional (state) law of foreign countries : a textbook]. Moscow, 2005. 400 p.

4. Gadzhi-Zade E.A. Konstitutsionnye modeli formy pravleniya i institut prezidentstva v stranakh SNG: dis. ... kand. yurid. nauk [Constitutional models of government and the Institute of presidency in the CIS : PhD Thesis]. Volgograd, 2005. 228 p.

5. Gelieva I.N. Nekotorye voprosy formy gosudarstvennogo pravleniya v Rossii [Some of the issues of the form of government in Russia]. Obshchestvo i pravo [Society and law]. 2008. No. 1. Pp. 42—45.

6. Zaznaev O.I. Osmyslenie form pravleniya v zarubezhnoy politicheskoy nauke: noveyshie diskussii [Understanding of forms of government in foreign political science: the latest discussions]. Politicheskaya nauka [Political science]. 2014. No. 1. Pp. 10—33.

7. Zaznaev O.I. Poluprezidentskaya sistema: teoreticheskie i prikladnye aspekty [Semi-presidential system: theoretical and applied aspects]. Kazan, 2006. 374 p.

8. Malinovskiy V.A. Lider: prezidentskaya vlast v Kazakhstane na rubezhe epokh [Leader: presidential power in Kazakhstan at the turn of eras]. Astana, 2012. 528 p.

9. Nechkin A.V. Konstitutsionno-pravovoy status pravitelstv stran Sodruzhestva Nezavisimykh Gosudarstv (sravnitelnoe issledovanie) [Constitutional and legal status of the governments of the Commonwealth of Independent States (comparative study)]. Moscow: Norma Publ., 2016. 176 p.

10. Nechkin A.V. Formy pravleniya v stranakh Sodruzhestva Nezavisimykh Gosudarstv [Forms of government in the Commonwealth of Independent States]. Moscow: Norma Publ., 2018. 208 p.

11. Osavelyuk A.M. Forma pravleniya i gosudarstvennyy rezhim po konstitutsii Rossiyskoy Federatsii: optionsvarianty poiska effektivnosti osushchestvleniya gosudarstvennoy vlasti [Form of government and state regime according to the Constitution of the Russian Federation: options for finding the effectiveness of the exercise of state power]. Konstitutsionnoe i munitsipalnoe pravo [Constitutional and municipal law]. 2014. No. 2. Pp. 22—25.

12. Rozhkova L.P. Printsipy i metody tipologii gosudarstva i prava [Principles and methods of typology of state and law]. Saratov, 1984. 116 p.

13. Sadokhina N.E. Dualizm formy pravleniya v sovremennykh gosudarstvakh [Dualism of the form of government in modern States]. Vestnik TGU [Tomsk State University Journal]. Issue 12. Humanities. Law. 2013. Pp. 440—445.

14. Selutina E.N. Problemy klassifikatsii form gosudarstvennogo pravleniya v sovremennykh usloviyakh [Problems of classification of forms of government in modern conditions]. Uchenye zapiski Orlovskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta [Scientific notes of Orel State University]. 2013. No. 4. Pp. 39—42.

15. Teoriya gosudarstva i prava : uchebnik [Theory of state and law : a textbook]. Edited by V.D. Perevalov. Moscow, 2011. 496 p.

16. Khudoley D.M. Osnovnye, gibridnye i atipichnye formy pravleniya [Basic, hybrid and atypical forms of government]. Vestnik Permskogo universiteta [Bulletin of Perm University]. Legal sciences. 2010. Issue. 4. Pp. 53—65.

17. Khudoley K.M. Konstitutsionnoe pravo zarubezhnykh stran SNG i Baltii [Constitutional law of foreign CIS and Baltic countries]. Perm, 2009. 240 p.

18. Chirkin V.E. Zakonodatelnaya vlast [Legislature]. Moscow, 2015. 336 p.

19. . Chirkin V.E. Netipichnye formy pravleniya v sovremennom gosudarstve [Atypical forms of government in the modern state]. Gosudarstvo i pravo [State and law]. 1994. No. 1. Pp. 109—115.

20. Semi-presidentialism in Europe. R. Elgie (ed.). Oxford, 1999. 334 p.