Problems of Smart Contracts Application in Transactions in Virtual Property

The author examines the features of the use of smart contracts in transactions in virtual property, taking into account the fact that the smart contract is a way of fulfilling those obligations in which the transfer of property provision takes place in the virtual world with the help of appropriate technical means. It should be recognized that the list of virtual property is open, at the moment it includes, for example, cryptocurrency, domain names, «game property», virtual tokens.

The question of the legal nature of objects related to virtual property is relevant: are they a new independent type of property requiring special legal regimes, or are they a form of known property rights? The paper also notes that smart contracts differ in both vulnerabilities in computer code and insufficiently effective legal regulation. Smart contract, in the opinion of the author, is a kind of written (electronic) form of a contract, the peculiarity of which is that the will of the subject is expressed by means of special technical means in the form of program code. In this case, the will to conclude the contract simultaneously means the will to its execution upon the occurrence of certain conditions of the contract circumstances.

In conclusion, the author shows that the automation of performance of obligations in particular and the digitization of contract law in general should not create obstacles to the implementation of the fundamental principles of good faith and contractual justice, to assess the proportionality of the distribution of rights and obligations of the parties, the equivalence of their property.

1. Vashkevich A. Pyat vyvodov o smart-kontraktakh [Five conclusions about smart contracts]. Zakon.ru. 27.12.2017.

2. Efimova L.G., Sizemova O. B. Pravovaya priroda smart-kontrakta [Legal nature of the smart contract]. Bankovskoe pravo [Banking law]. 2019. No. 1. Pp. 23—30.

3. Lukoyanov N.V. Pravovye aspekty zaklyucheniya, izmeneniya i prekrashcheniya smart-kontraktov [Legal aspects of the conclusion, amendment and termination of smart contracts]. Yuridicheskie issledovaniya [Legal studies]. 2018. No. 11. Pp. 28-35. DOI: 10.25136/2409-7136.2018.11.28115. URL: http://e-notabene. ru/lr/article_28115.html.

4. Novoselova L. «Tokenizatsiya» obektov grazhdanskogo prava [«Tokenization» of objects of civil law]. Khoziaistvo i Pravo [Economy and law]. 2017. No. 12. Pp. 29—44.

5. Rozhkova M. Tsifrovye aktivy i virtualnoe imushchestvo: kak sootnositsya virtualnoe s tsifrovym [Digital assets and virtual property: how virtual correlates with digital]. Zakon.ru.13.06.2018.

6. Sabo N. Umnye kontrakty (chetvertaya revolyutsiya stoimosti) [Smart contracts (Fourth value revolution)]. URL: http://old.computerra.ru/1998/266/194332/.

7. Saveliev A.I. Nekotorye pravovye aspekty ispolzovaniya smart-kontraktov i blokcheyn-tekhnologiy po rossiyskomu pravu [Some legal aspects of the use of smart contracts and blockchain technologies under Russian law]. Zakon [Law]. 2017. No. 5. Pp. 94—117.

8. Saveliev A.I. Nekotorye riski tokenizatsii i blokcheynizatsii grazhdansko-pravovykh otnosheniy [Some of the risks of tokenization and blockchainization of civil-legal relations]. Zakon [Law]. 2018. No. 2. Pp. 36—51.

9. Savelyev A. Chast 3. Yuridicheskaya definitsiya smart-kontrakta [Part 3. The legal definition of a smart contract]. Zakon.ru. 30.12.2017.

10. Sannikova L.V., Kharitonov Yu.S. Pravovaya sushchnost novykh tsifrovykh aktivov [Legal essence of the new digital assets]. Zakon [Law]. 2018. No. 9. Pp. 86—95.

11. Tyulkanov A. Blokcheynu — da, smart-kontraktam — net: zakonodateli nevady opredelilis s ponyatiyami [Yes to Blockchain, No to smart contracts: Nevada legislators have decided on the concepts]. Zakon.ru. 2017. URL: https://zakon.ru/blog/2017/06/19/blokchejnu_-_da_smart-kontraktam_-_net_zakonodateli_ nevady_opredelilis_s_ponyatiyami.

12. Yurasov M.Yu., Pozdnyakov D.A. Smart-kontrakt i perspektivy ego pravovogo regulirovaniya v epokhu tekhnologii blokcheyn [Smart contract and prospects of its legal regulation in the era of blockchain technology]. Zakon.ru

13. Levi S.D., Lipton A.B. An Introduction to Smart Contracts and Their Potential and Inherent Limits. Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher & Flom LLP. May 26, 2018.

14. Tjong Tjin Tai E. Formalizing Contract Law for Smart Contracts (September 18, 2017). Tilburg Private Law Working Paper Series, No. 6/2017. URL: https://ssrn.com/abstract=303880.

15. Szabo N. The Idea of Smart Contracts. URL: http://www.fon.hum.uva.nl/rob/Courses/InformationInSpeech/ CDROM/Literature/LOTwinterschool2006/.