Encouragement to Commit Suicide or Assisting with Suicide: Critical Analysis

Taking into account recent changes in criminal legislation, the paper critically analyzes the features of a newly introduced crime in the criminal code, such as encouraging to commit suicide or assisting with suicide (article 110.1). Special attention is given to the methods of encouraging and facilitating suicide in terms of their validity, accuracy, content and the need to list them in the criminal law. Examples of excessive detail in the formulation of certain criminogenic characteristics are given, which contradicts the principles of legal technique. These include features such as persuasions, suggestions, advice, instructions, information, and a promise to conceal the tools or means of committing suicide. The elements of these crimes are considered in detail from the point of view of their relevance and reflection of the degree of public danger of the committed acts. This statement refers to such characteristics of victims that aggravate criminal responsibility, such as the age of a minor, the state of pregnancy, financial or other dependence on the perpetrator. The author proposes solutions for the classification of disputable situations when the crimes in question are committed against minors, the insane, or persons suffering from mental disorders. The paper considers cases when the studied crimes may be committed by a criminal community, and lists options for the classification of what was done. Special attention is given to the classification of encouragement to commit a terrorist act by self-detonation. The issue of responsibility of a minor who encourages a minor to commit suicide or contributes to his / her suicide has been raised as a matter of discussion. Proposals are made to improve the disposition of the criminal law norm. The author expresses reproaches to the notes to article 110.2 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation, which provides exemption from criminal responsibility in the commission of the investigated crime, and proposes a new edition of notes, which must be placed after the text of article 110.1 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation, taking into account characteristics of the main and aggravated offenses.

inducement, assistance, persuasion, deception, bribery, advice, promise to hide the tools or means of crime, aggravated elements that characterize the individual characteristics of the victim, classification of crimes committed against minors, etc. victims, cases of commission of a crime by a criminal community, inducement to a terrorist act, grounds for exemption from criminal responsibility, proposals for improving the criminal law and notes to it

1. Babaev M, Pudovochkin Yu. «Mertvye normy» v ugolovnom kodekse: problemy i resheniya ["Dead norms" in the Criminal Code: Problems and solutions]. Ugolovnoe pravo. 2010;6:4—10.

2. Borzenkov G. Ob uchete printsipov ugolovnogo prava v zakonotvorcheskoy deyatelnosti [On considering the principles of criminal law in law-making activities]. Ugolovnoe pravo. 2011;3:4—7.

3. Borzenkov GN. Prestupleniya protiv zhizni i zdorovya: zakon i pravoprimenitelnaya praktika: ucheb.-prakt. posobie [Crimes against life and health: law and law enforcement practice: A textbook]. Moscow; 2008.

4. Korneeva VA. Iz dvukh zol menshee kak printsip kvalifikatsii prestupleniy [The lesser of the two evils as the principle of classifying crimes]. In: Ugolovnoe pravo: strategiya razvitiya v XXI veke [Criminal law development strategy in the 21st century]. Moscow; 2016. P. 46—50.

5. Krukovskiy VE, Mosechkin IN. Ugolovno-pravovye problemy protivodeystviya deyatelnosti, napravlennoy na pobuzhdenie k soversheniyu ubiystv i samoubiystv [Criminal legal problems of counteraction to activities aimed at encouraging murder and suicide]. Zhurnal Vysshey shkoly ekonomiki [Journal of the Higher School of Economics]. 2018;4:196—215.

6. Korobeev AI, editor. Polnyy kurs ugolovnogo prava: v 5 t. Prestupleniya protiv lichnosti [Complete course on criminal law: in 5 vols. Vol. 2: Crimes against the person]. St. Petersburg; 2008.

7. Shcherba SP, editor. Sravnitelnoe ugolovnoe pravo. Osobennaya chast: monografiya [Comparative criminal law. Special part: monograph]. Moscow; 2010.