“Every Scientifically Educated Lawyer Should be a Cultural Fighter for the Ideals of Law in Life!“ — Nikolay I. Palienko’s Legal and Political Views

. The paper analyzes the legal views of Nikolay I. Palienko, a prominent philosopher of law and a state historian of the beginning of the last century. The authors pay significant attention to the integrative concept of legal understanding that is followed by Prof. Nikolay Palienko. They also substantiate originality and significance of the concept in the light of modernization of the political and legal order in late imperial Russia. It seems that under certain conditions it could serve as a bridge between positivist jurisprudence and the doctrine of “reborn natural law” developed in pre-revolutionary Russia. It was intended to smooth out the contradictions in both doctrines and contribute to the development of a new methodology for law understanding in the context of transformation of the Russian legal system towards establishing institutions of constitutional order.

On the basis of published sources, the authors show the evolution of the scholar’s views from the positivist theory of law to idealism that is not properly estimated in the legal literature and is quite typical for the legal scholars of the interrevolutionary period.

The authors conclude that Prof. Nikolay I. Palienko scholarship and knowledge allowed him to substantiate his own concept of legal understanding that can be considered integrative on the basis of achievements of the positivist theory of law, philosophy of natural law, psychological and sociological concepts of legal understanding. Prof. Palienko proclaimed the normative nature of law and at the same time expressed ideas of the supremacy of law over the state and the coherence of the state provided by law. An essential element of his legal concept was the legal consciousness of the society, acknowledgement of its role in the course of law education, as well as its establishment as a source of law. Palienko’s idea of legal coherence of the state represents a synthesis of positivism with idealism and leads to a new stage of development of legal methodology and ideology, namely: integrative jurisprudence. Scholar’s political and legal ideas contributed to the development of ideas about the rule of law, which were very popular in Russia during the period of development of representative institutions and constitutionalism.

1. Vlasov VI. Vklad G. F. Shershenevicha v razvitie otechestvennoy teorii gosudarstva i prava [G. Shershenevich’s contribution to the development of the national theory of state and law]. In: Legal positivism and competition of theories of law: history and modernity (to the 100th anniversary of the death of G. Shershenevich): Proceedings of the VI International Scientific and Practical Conference, Ivanovo, October 5-8, 2012;25-31. Ivanovo: Ivanovo State University Publ.; 2012 (In Russ.).

2. Grafsky VG. O nekotorykh neadekvatnykh istolkovaniyakh yuridicheskogo pozitivizma [On some inadequate interpretations of legal positivism]. In: Legal positivism and competition of theories of law: history and modernity (to the 100th anniversary of the death of G. Shershenevich): Proceedings of the 6th International Scientific and Practical Conference, Ivanovo, October 5-8, 2012;25-31. Ivanovo: Ivanovo State University Publ.; 2012 (In Russ.).

3. Egorov SA. Vydayushchiysya gosudarstvoved i teoretik prava N. I. Palienko [Prominent state historian and theorist of law N. I. Palienko]. In: Problems of the theory of law and state, histories of political and legal thought: a collection of works by students, friends and colleagues of Professor O. O. E. Leist. Almaty: AYu— HSL “Dilet”; 2005 (In Russ.).

4. Kokoshkin FF. Yuridicheskaya priroda manifesta 17 oktyabrya [The legal nature of the Manifesto of October 17]. Yuridicheskiy vestnik [Juridical Herald]. Book 1. Moscow; 1913 (In Russ.).

5. Kornev VN. Problemy teorii gosudarstva v liberalnoy pravovoy mysli Rossii kontsa XIX — XX veka [Problems of the theory of the state in the liberal legal thought of Russia of the late 19th — 20th century]. Moscow: Yurlitinform Publ.; 2005 (In Russ.).

6. Leist OE. Sushchnost prava.problemy teorii i filosofii prava [The essence of law. Problems of theory and philosophy of law]. Moscow: Zertsalo-M Publ.; 2002 (In Russ.).

7. Lushnikov AM. Yaroslavskaya yuridicheskaya shkola : uchebno-metodicheskie rekomendatsii [Yaroslavl Law School: educational and methodical recommendations]. Yaroslavl: Yaroslavl State University Publ.; 2011 (In Russ.).

8. Maksimov SI. Palienko Nikolay — pravoved, spetsialist v oblasti gosudarstvennogo prava i filosofii prava [Palienko Nikolay — legal scholar, specialist in the field of state law and philosophy of law]. In: State, political and public figures of Ukraine. Political portraits. Book 1. Moscow; 2002 (In Russ.).

9. Martyshin OV. Sovmestimy li osnovnye tipy pravoponimaniya? [Are the basic types of legal understanding compatible?]. State and Law. 2003;6:13-19 (In Russ.).

10. Medushevsky AN. Dialog so vremenem. Rossiyskie konstitutsionalisty kontsa XIX — nachala XX veka [Dialogue withr time. Russian constitutionalists of the late 19th — early 20th century]. Moscow: Novyi Chronograph Publ.; 2010 (In Russ.).

11. Medushevskiy AN Kokoshkin FF. Rossiyskiy liberalizm serediny XVIII — nachala XX v. [Russian liberalism of the middle of the 18th — early 20th century]. In: Shelokhaev VV, editor. Encyclopedia. Moscow: Rosspan Publ.; 2010 (In Russ.).

12. Novgorodtsev PI. Pravo i gosudarstvo [Law and the state]. Voprosy filosofii and psikhologii. Book 75(V). Moscow; 1904 (In Russ.).

13. Palienko NI. Zadachi i predely yuridicheskogo izucheniya gosudarstva i noveyshee formalno-yuridicheskoe issledovanie problem gosudarstvennogo prava [Tasks and limits of legal study of the state and the latest formal legal study of the problems of state law]. St. Petersburg: Senate Printing House; 1912 (In Russ.).

14. . Palienko NI. Pravovoe znachenie Manifesta 17 oktyabrya 1905 goda [Legal significance of the Manifesto of October 17, 1905]. Yuridicheskiy vestnik [Juridical Herald]. Book XI (III); 1915 (In Russ.).

15. Palienko NI. Predmet i zadacha entsiklopedii prava i ideya prava [The subject and task of the encyclopedia of law and the idea of law]. Yaroslavl: E. G. Falk Publishing House; 1900 (In Russ.).

16. Palienko NI. Uchenie o sushchestve prava i pravovoy svyazannosti gosudarstva [The doctrine on the substance of law and legal connectedness of the state]. Kharkiv: M. Zilberberg & Sons Publishing House; 1908 (In Russ.).

17. Popova AV. Teoretiko-pravovoe issledovanie neoliberalnoy politiko-pravovoy doktriny v Rossii (konets XIX — nachalo XX v.) : avtoref. dis. ... d-ra yurid. nauk [Theoretical and legal study of neoliberal political and legal doctrine in Russia (late 19th — early 20th century): Author’s Abstract]. Moscow; 2014 (In Russ.).

18. Sokolova AA. Yuridicheskiy pozitivizm g. f. shershenevicha: sovremennoe prochtenie [Legal positivism of G. F. Shershenevich: modern reading]. In: Legal positivism and competition of theories of law: history and modernity (to the 100th anniversary of the death of G. F. Shershenevich): Proceedings of the VI International Scientific and Practical Conference. Part 1. October 5—8, Ivanovo: Ivanovo State University; 2012 (In Russ.).

19. Tumanova AS, Kiselev RV. Prava cheloveka v pravovoy mysli i zakonotvorchestve rossiyskoy imperii vtoroy poloviny XIX — nachala XX veka [Human rights in legal thought and lawmaking of the Russian Empire of the second half of the 19th — early 20th century]. Moscow: Higher School of Economics Publ.; 2011 (In Russ.).

20. Marchenko MN, editor. Filosofiya prava : kurs lektsiy : ucheb. posobie : v 2 t [Philosophy of law: course of lectures: textbook: in 2 vol]. Vol. 1. Moscow: Prospekt Publ.; 2013 (In Russ.).

21. Frolova EA. Filosofiya prava v rossii. Neokantianstvo (vtoraya polovina XIX — pervaya polovina XX veka) [Philosophy of law in Russia. Neocantianism (second half of th 19th — first half of the 20th century). Moscow: Prospekt Publ.; 2019 (In Russ.).

22. Hol Dzh. integrativnaya yurisprudentsiya [Integrative jurisprudence]. In: Anthology of World Legal Thought: in 5 Vol. Vol. 3. Moscow; 1999 (In Russ.).

23. Shershenevich GF. Obshchaya teoriya prava [General Theory of Law]. Moscow: Bashmakov Brothers Publ.; 1911 (In Russ.).

24. Grafskiy BG, editor. Entsiklopediya pravovedeniya ili integralnaya yurisprudentsiya? Problemy izucheniya i prepodavaniya : materialy sedmykh filosofsko-pravovykh chteniy pamyati akademika V. S. Nersesyantsa [Encyclopedia of Jurisprudence or Integral Jurisprudence? Problems of the study and teaching: Proceedings of seventh philosophical and legal readings in memory of academician V. S. Nersesyants]. Moscow: Norma Publ.; 2013 (In Russ.).

25. Tumanova AS. The liberal doctrine of civil rights in Late Imperial Russia: a history of the struggle for the rule of law. Cahiers du Monde Russe. 2016;57(4);792-809.