Theoretical Aspects of Determining the Place of Energy (Energy Resources) in the System of Civil Rights Objects

The paper is devoted to determining the role of energy in the system of civil rights objects. The author highlights two main theories. Representatives of the first theory recognize energy as a thing and, accordingly consider it possible to apply the property law regime in relation to it. Currently, the number of supporters of this theory has increased due to the fact that the legislator consolidated regulatory norms regarding the energy supply contract in the chapter of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation devoted to purchase-and-sale transactions. The doctrine also attempts to justify the extension of the property right to energy through the category of «disembodied things». The second theory denies the attribution of energy to things. Representatives of this theory try to substantiate the legal nature of energy based on the existing systematization of objects of civil rights. According to the author, energy is an independent object of civil rights, a special object of a physical nature, having no sign of materiality, capable of generation and, under certain conditions, transfer in economic relations of civil turnover participants, and considered as a commodity with property value and high socioeconomic importance. Thus, energy perfectly fits into the category reserved by the law-maker for similar new objects and classified as «other property». Denying the substantive qualification of energy, the author supports the position of researchers who consider energy exclusively as an object of binding rights, since, given its physical nature and the possibility of generation and transmission exclusively through technical infrastructure, energy as an independent object of civil rights can act exclusively as a subject of binding legal relations

1. Abova TE, Kabalkina AYu (eds.). Commentary to the Civil Code of the Russian Federation. Moscow; 2003. (In Russ.).

2. Agarkov MM. Podryad: Tekst i kommentariy k st. 220–235 Grazhdanskogo kodeksa [In a row: Text and commentary to Articles 220–235 of the Civil Code]. Moscow: Pravo i zhyzn’ Publ. 1924. (In Russ.).

3. Alekseev SS. Property and Law: Actual Problems. Tsivilisticheskie zapiski: mezhvuzovskiy sbornik nauchnykh trudov. Issue 2. Moscow: Statute Publ.; Yekaterinburg: Private Law Institute Publ.; 2002. (In Russ.).

4. Belova EB. Energy as an independent object of rights. Yurist. 2019;6:37-43. (In Russ.).

5. Blinkova EV. Civil law regulation of the supply of goods through the connected network: Theoretical, methodological and practical problems of unity and differentiation. Moscow: Yurist Publ.; 2005. (In Russ.).

6. Braginskiy MI. The general doctrine of business contracts. Minsk; 1967. (In Russ.).

7. Brynova TI. Disputes related to the application of legislation regulating relations under the contract for the provision of services for the transmission of electric energy. Arbitrazhnye spory [Arbitrazh disputes]. 2013;2:17- 34. (In Russ.).

8. Chausskaya OA. Civil Law. A textbook for students of educational institutions of secondary vocational education. Moscow: Dashkov and K Publ.; 2007. (In Russ.).

9. Dzhazoyan EA. The category of fiction in civil law. Cand. Diss. (Law). Moscow; 2006. (In Russ.).

10. Faustov SA. Legal regulation of electricity and heat supply in the energy supply system in the Russian Federation. Cand. Diss. (Law). Moscow; 2005. (In Russ.).

11. Gambarov YuS. The «thing» section of the Encyclopedic Dictionary of the Russian Bibliographic Institute of Pomegranates. Vol. 10. Moscow; 1937. (In Russ.).

12. Gambarov YuS. The course of civil law. Vol. 1: The general part. St. Petersburg; 1911. (In Russ.).

13. Gorodov OA. Introduction to Energy Law. Moscow; 2015. (In Russ.)

14. Grimm DD. To the doctrine of the objects of rights. Civil Law Herald. 2007;1.

15. Kantser YuA. About the subject matter of the energy supply contract. Sovetnik yurista. 2015;5:35-49. (In Russ.).

16. Khorosheva NV. Public Energy Supply Contract: problems when concluding by joining. Civil Law. 2016;3:17-34. (In Russ.).

17. Korneev SM. The legal nature of the energy supply contract. Zakon. 1995;7:118-121. (In Russ.).

18. Krassov EO. The system of contractual relations in the field of organization of electric energy supply. CCand. Diss. (Law). Moscow; 2009. (In Russ.).

19. Lakhno PG. Energy as an object of legal regulation. Ecology and Energy. 2007;40:10-19. (In Russ.).

20. Lapach LV. The problem of the structure of the category «property» in Russian civil law. Cand. Diss. (Law). Rostov-on-Don; 2007. (In Russ.).

21. Lukyantseva IA. The legal nature of electricity as an object of civil rights. Journal of Russian Law. 2008;3:53- 61. (In Russ.).

22. Lysenko AN. «Disembodied things» in civil law: approaches to the definition of content. Available at: http:// www.yurclub.ru/. (In Russ.).

23. Lysenko AN. Property in the civil law of Russia. Moscow: Delovoy Dvor Publ.; 2010. (In Russ.).

24. Matiyashchuk SV. Electric energy and power as special objects of civil turnover: issues of theory and practice. Journal of Russian Law. 2008;12:94-99. (In Russ.).

25. Matiyashchuk SV. Legal regulation of contractual relations in the field of electricity and heat supply. Moscow; 2011. (In Russ.).

26. Mattei U, Sukhanov EA. The main provisions of the right of ownership. Moscow; 1999. (In Russ.).

27. Mikhailov DI. Public utilities as an object of civil rights. Novyi juridicheskiy zhurnal. 2012;4:97-106. (In Russ.).

28. Murzin DV. Securities are disembodied things. Legal problems of the modern theory of securities. Moscow: Statute Publ.; 1998. (In Russ.).

29. Nestolii VG. The energy supply contract is an independent institute of Russian civil law. Siberian Law Herald. 2003;3:

30. Pleshakov NV. Problems of legal regulation of contractual relations in the wholesale electricity market. Cand. Diss. (Law).Moscow; 2005. (In Russ.).

31. Pobedonostsev KP. The course of civil law. The first part: Patrimonial rights. Essay by K. Pobedonostsev, honorary member of the Universities of Moscow, St. Petersburg and Kazan. 3rd edition. St. Petersburg: Printing House of the Ministry of Railways (A. Behnke); 1883. (In Russ.).

32. Rozin NN. On the theft of electric energy. Vestnik prava. 1899;10. (In Russ.).

33. Sadikov ON (ed.). Commentary to the Civil Code of the Russian Federation. Part I (article by article). Moscow: Jurist Publ.; 1998. (In Russ.).

34. Sergeev AP, Tolstoy YuK (eds.). Civil Law. Vol. 2. Moscow; 2003. (In Russ.).

35. Shershenevich GF. Textbook of commercial law. Moscow: Moskovskoe nauchnoe isdatel’stvo; 1919. Sinitsyn SA. General provisions on property law: comparative law research. Moscow: Infotropik Media Publ.; 2019. (In Russ.).

36. Sklovskiy KI. Ownership in civil law. Moscow: Statute Publ.; 2010. (In Russ.).

37. Sukhanov EA (ed.). Civil Law. Vol. 1. Moscow; 1998. (In Russ.).

38. Sukhanov EA (ed.). Civil Law. Vol. 2. Moscow; 1994. (In Russ.).

39. Svirkov SA. Civil law regulation in the field of energy supply. Dr. Diss. (Law). Moscow; 2019. (In Russ.).

40. Svirkov SA. The main problems of civil law regulation of energy turnover. Moscow: Statute Publ.; 2013. (In Russ.).

41. Symbolokov OA. Contracts in the electric power industry: problems of theory and practice. Moscow: Infotropik Media Publ.; 2021. (In Russ.).

42. Tarkhov VA, Rybakov VA. Ownership and ownership rights. Ufa; 2001. (In Russ.).

43. Tebenkova SA. Electric energy as an object of civil rights. Yurist. 2015;3:21-25. (In Russ.).

44. Truntsevskiy YuV, Ruchkin OYu, Shumov AA. The contract of energy supply in the retail markets of electric energy. Moscow: Yurist Publ.; 2010. (In Russ.).