Legislative Problems of Mandatory Medical Measures (Chapter 15 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation)

The paper discusses the author’s draft of Chapter 15 of the Criminal code of the Russian Federation with a brief comment prepared by Professor G.V. Nazarenko and published in the journal in the framework of the correspondence round table «New Criminal Code of Russia: Conceptual Framework and Theoretical Model». The new title of Chapter 15 proposed in the draft is being discussed, which, like its current title, does not indicate that the measures in question are psychiatric in content. The authors themselves distinguish two types of such measures: «mandatory» in the strict sense of the word, applied to subjects with severe mental disorders, excluding sanity or making impossible the appointment or execution of punishment, and «obligatory», applied to convicts with mental disorders within the limits of sanity. In this regard, it is proposed to name Chapter 15 «Mandatory and obligatory psychiatric measures». The paper discusses the rationale and purpose of the application of mandatory psychiatric measures. According to the authors, the criminal law should disclose the content of the «danger criterion» and define it as a real possibility (a high degree of probability) of committing new acts by this person, provided for in the articles of the Special part of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation. Analyzing the proposed by G.V. Nazarenko definition of the purposes for the use of mandatory psychiatric measures, the authors believe that it is hardly appropriate to declare such a «change» of the mental state of a person with a mental disorder «which eliminates its social danger» as their purpose. Mandatory psychiatric measures should be aimed solely at improving the mental state of the patient, while the elimination of the danger may in some cases be the result not of an improvement, but of the deterioration of his / her condition or the influence of other unfavourable medical factors. It is concluded that, despite the divergence of scientific positions on a number of issues, the author’s draft of Chapter 15 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation, prepared by G.V. Nazarenko, is a significant contribution to the theoretical understanding of the current criminal law governing mandatory medical measures, and outlines generally right directions for its improvement.

1. Batanov A.N. Tseli prinuditelnykh mer meditsinskogo kharaktera [Goals of compulsory medical measures]. Nauka v sovremennom mire : materialy XXXI mezhdunarodnoy nauchno-prakticheskoy konferentsii : sbornik nauchnykh trudov [Science in the modern world : Proc. of the XXXI International scientific and practical conference : collection of scientific papers]. G.I. Rogalev (sci.ed.). Moscow: Pero Publ. 2018. Pp. 185—189.

2. Gerasina Yu.A. O neobkhodimosti sovershenstvovaniya polozheniy glavy 15 ugolovnogo kodeksa Rossiyskoy Federatsii [About need of improvement of provisions of Chapter 15 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation]. Uchenye zapiski Orlovskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta [Scientific notes of the Orel State University]. 2013. No. 5 (55). Pp. 161—164.

3. Dmitrieva T.B., Tkachenko A.A., Kharitonova N.K., Shishkov S.N. Sudebnaya psikhiatriya : uchebnoe posobie [Forensic psychiatry : A Study Guide]. Moscow: Meditsinskoe informatsionnoe agentstvo Publ., 2008. 752 p.

4. Kalinina T.M. Prinuditelnye mery meditsinskogo kharaktera: mery gosudarstvennogo prinuzhdeniya ili mery bezopasnosti? [Mandatory measures of medical nature: measures of state coercion or security measures?]. Aktualnye problemy rossiyskogo prava [Actual problems of Russian law]. 2009. No. 1 (10). Pp. 342—348.

5. Kolmakov P.A. O nekotorykh problemnykh situatsiyakh pravovogo regulirovaniya prinuditelnykh mer meditsinskogo kharaktera [Some problematic situations of legal regulation of compulsory medical measures]. Vestnik Udmurtskogo universiteta. Seriya: Ekonomika i pravo [Bulletin of the Udmurt University. Series: Economics and law]. 2017. Vol. 27. Issue. 2. Pp.105—107.

6. Loshchinkin V.V. K voprosu o yuridicheskoy prirode prinuditelnykh mer meditsinskogo kharaktera [The legal nature of mandatory medical measures]. Vestnik Tomskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. Pravo [Tomsk State University Journal. Law]. 2015. No. 3 (17). Pp. 32—39.

7. Nazarenko G.V. Pravovaya priroda prinuditelnykh mer meditsinskogo kharaktera [Legal nature of mandatory medical measures]. Vestnik Omskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta im. F.M. Dostoevskogo. Seriya: Pravo [Herald of Omsk University. Series : Law]. 2008. No. (17). Pp. 130—134.

8. Nazarenko G.V. Prinuditelnye mery meditsinskogo vozdeystviya: razdel «mery obshchestvennoy bezopasnosti» [Mandatory medical measures: section «Public security measures»]. Lex Russica. 2017. No. 8. Pp. 101—111.

9. Soshina L.A. K voprosu o zakonodatelnom opredelenii termina «prinuditelnye mery meditsinskogo kharaktera» [The question of the legislative definition of the term «compulsory medical measures»]. Sibirskiy yuridicheskiy vestnik [Siberian Law Herald]. 2010. No. 1. Pp. 45—50.

10. Soshina L.A. Tseli prinuditelnykh mer meditsinskogo kharaktera i ikh pravovaya obuslovlennost v UK RF [Purposes of mandartory measures of medical character and their legal conditionality of the Criminal Code of Russian Federation]. Sibirskiy yuridicheskiy vestnik [Siberian Law Herald]. 2011. No. 2. Pp. 106—111.

11. Punigov A.S. Inye mery ugolovno-pravovogo kharaktera (ponyatie, vidy, obshchaya kharakteristika): monografiya [Other measures of criminal law (concept, types, general characteristics) : monograph]. Edited by A.I. Chuchaev. Vladimir, 2007. 188 p.

12. Ugolovnyy kodeks Rossiyskoy Federatsii (nauchnyy proekt) [Criminal Code of the Russian Federation (research project)]. N.A. Lopashenko, R.O. Dolotov, E.V. Kobzeva, K.M. Khuto; edited by N.A. Lopashenko. Moscow: Yurlitinform Publ., 2019. 320 p.

13. Khritinin D.F., Kotov V.P., Rukovodstvo po sudebnoy psikhiatrii [Guidelines for forensic psychiatry]. Edited by D.F. Khritinin. Moscow: Nauchnaya biblioteka Publ., 2017. 740 p.

14. Shishkov S.N., Polubinskaya S.V. O dvukh tipakh prinuditelnykh mer meditsinskogo kharaktera [On two types of compulsory medical measures]. Ugolovnoe pravo: strategiya razvitiya v XXI veke: materialy XII mezhdunarodnoy nauchno-prakticheskoy konferentsii (29—30 yanvarya 2015 g.) [Criminal law: development strategy for the 21st century : Proc. of the XII International scientific and practical conference (29-30 January 2015). Moscow: RG-Press, 2015. Pp. 303—306.

15. Appelbaum P. S. Almost A Revolution: Mental Health Law and the Limits of Change. New York, Oxford : Oxford University Press, 1994. 233 p.

16. Bonnie R.J., Coughlin M.A., Jeffries J.C. Jr., Low P.W. Criminal Law. New York. : Foundation Press, 2010. 1225 p.