Electronic Evidence in the Criminal Procedure Code: To Be or not to Be?

Digital reality has firmly entered the life of society and the state. It has also become a solid medium and a means of committing crimes, the digital (electronic) traces of which law enforcement and judicial authorities use to restore the picture of the event. Various digital devices (mobile phones, tablets, smartphones, flash drives, hard drives, etc.), carrying important information for the preliminary investigation and the court, fall into the orbit of the criminal process. It is often impossible to withdraw, investigate, consolidate this information without the participation of a specialist. The current criminal procedure legislation is not fully adapted to such sources of information. Therefore, digital novels of reality become the object of study of many sciences of the criminal law cycle, including the science of criminal procedure law. Is it necessary to include the concept of «electronic evidence» in the criminal procedure legislation? If necessary, are there grounds for concluding that this type of evidence is independent, or can electronic evidence be classified as one of the traditional types of evidence? What are the theoretical and practical prerequisites for this? What are the features of electronic evidence? In science, there are different points of view on these issues. Most scientists and experts believe it is possible to classify electronic evidence as either physical evidence or other documents. In the paper, it is offered to consider these evidence as an independent type of evidence, treating them as electronic carriers of information, and electronic information in the form of electronic documents. Based on the proposed theoretical proposals, it is necessary to begin the development of appropriate legal norms for their inclusion in the criminal procedure law.

electronic evidence, evidence, establishment of evidence, types of evidence, criminal procedure, evaluation of evidence, law enforcement, electronic media

1. Aleksandrov A.S., Kuvychkov S.I. O nadezhnosti «elektronnykh dokazatelstv v ugolovnom protsesse [On the reliability of «electronic evidence» in criminal procedure]. URL: https://docplayer.ru/26470841-O-nadezhnostielektronnyh-dokazatelstv-v-ugolovnom-processe.html.

2. Vasyukov V.F. Izyatie elektronnykh nositeley informatsii: inereshennye problemy praktiki [Seizure of electronic media: unresolved practice issues]. Ugolovnyy protsess [Criminal Procedure]. 2016. No. 2.

3. Gavrilin Yu.V. Elektronnye nositeli informatsii v ugolovnom sudoproizvodstve [Electronic media in criminal procedure]. Trudy Akademii upravleniya MVD Rossii [Procs of the Academy of Management of the Ministry of the Interior of Russia]. 2017. No. 4 (44).

4. Galyashina E.I. Otsenka dostovernosti tsifrovykh fonogramm v ugolovnom protsesse [Assessment of the reliability of digital phonograms in criminal proceedings]. Dokazyvanie i prinyatie resheniy v sovremennom ugolovnom sudoproizvodstve: materialy mezhdunarodnoy nauchno-prakticheskoy konferentsii, posvyashchennoy pamyati d-ra yurid. nauk, prof. Poliny Abramovny Lupinskoy: sbornik nauchnykh trudov [Evidence and decision-making in modern criminal procedure: Procs of the International scientific and practical conference dedicated to the memory of Prof. Polina Abramovna Lupinskaya : collection of papers]. Moscow: Elit Publ., 2011.

5. Dokazyvanie v ugolovnom protsesse: uchebnik dlya bakalavriata i magistratury [Establishment of evidence in criminal procedure: A textbook for undergraduate and graduate studies]. V.A. Lazareva. 5th ed., rev. and suppl. Moscow: Yurayt Publ., 2014.

6. Doktrinalnaya model ugolovno-protsessualnogo dokazatelstvennogo prava RF i kommentariy k ney [Doctrinal model of criminal procedural evidentiary law of the Russian Federation and commentary to it]. A.S. Aleksandrov [et al.]. Moscow, 2015.

7. Zigura N.A., Kudryavtseva A.V. Kompyuternaya informatsiya kak vid dokazatelstva v ugolovnom protsesse Rossii: monografiya [Computer information as a kind of evidence in the criminal process of Russia: monograph]. Moscow, 2011.

8. Kurs ugolovnogo protsessa [The course of criminal trial]. Edited by Professor L.V. Golovko. Moscow: Statut Publ., 2016.

9. Marfitsin P.G. Nekotorye podkhody k formulirovaniyu ponyatiya «elektronnoe dokazatelstvo» v ugolovnom sudoproizvodstve [Some approaches to the formulation of the concept of «electronic evidence» in criminal proceedings]. Vestnik Nizhegorodskoy akademii MVD Rossii [Bulletin of the Nizhny Novgorod Academy of the Ministry of the Interior of Russia]. 2017. No. 3 (39).

10. Okanenko R.I. «Elektronnye dokazatelstva» i problemy obespecheniya prav grazhdan na zashchitu tayny lichnoy zhizni v ugolovnom protsesse: sravnitelnyy analiz zakonodatelstva Soedinennykh Shtatov Ameriki i Rossiyskoy Federatsii : dis. ... kand. yurid. nauk. [«Electronic evidence» and the problems of ensuring the rights of citizens to protect privacy in criminal proceedings: comparative analysis of the legislation of the United States of America and the Russian Federation : PhD Thesis]. Moscow, 2016.

11. Orlov Yu.K. Problemy teorii dokazatelstv v ugolovnom protsesse [Problems of the theory of evidence in criminal proceedings]. Moscow: Yurist Publ., 2009.

12. Osnovy teorii elektronnykh dokazatelstv: monografiya [Fundamentals of the theory of electronic evidence : monograph]. Edited by S.V. Zuev, Doctor of Law. Moscow: Yurlitinform Publ., 2019.

13. Pastukhov P.S. O razvitii ugolovno-protsessualnogo dokazyvaniya s ispolzovaniem elektronnykh dokazatelstv [On the development of criminal procedural evidence using electronic evidence].Legal reference system «Konsultant Plus:» [Electronic resource].

14. Rybin A.V. Elektronnyy dokument kak veshchestvennoe dokazatelstvo po delam o prestupleniyakh v sfere kompyuternoy informatsii (protsessualnye i kriminalisticheskie aspekty) [Electronic document as material evidence in cases of crimes in the field of computer information (procedural and forensic aspects)]. St. Petersburg, 2005.

15. Stelmakh V.Yu. Elektronnaya informatsiya v dokazyvanii po ugolovnym delam: sposoby polucheniya i mesto v sisteme dokazatelstv [Electronic information in evidence in criminal cases: methods of obtaining and place in the system of evidence]. Biblioteka kriminalista [Criminalist’s Library Scientific Journal]. 2018. No. 3.

16. Teoriya dokazatelstv v sovetskom ugolovnom protsesse [Evidence theory in the Soviet criminal trial]. Edited by N.V. Zhogin. 2nd ed. rev. and suppl. Moscow: Legal Literature Publ., 1973.

17. Ugolovno-protsessualnoe pravo Rossiyskoy Federatsii: uchebnik [Criminal procedure law of the Russian Federation: a textbook]. 3rd ed., rev. and suppl. Edited by I.L. Petrukhin, I.B. Mikhailovskaya. Moscow: Prospect Publ., 2010.