An Inheritance Contract: a Critical Look at the Legal Construction

The legal structure of an inheritance contract introduced into the system of Russian civil law on June 1, 2019, caused an ambiguous evaluation in the doctrine of inheritance law. Analyzing various points of views of scholars and legal prescriptions, the author expresses her opinion on this legal structure highlighting in particular an imbalance in the legal status of the parties to the inheritance contract, expressed in the possibility of unilateral refusal to execute it by only one of the parties, in the absence of legal protection of the testator's counterparty when the latter alienates the property specified in the inheritance contract. This makes this legal structure practically non-binding for the testator and reduces its relevance. The author substantiates that the legal prohibition of concluding an inheritance contract through a representative applies only to the testator. The assumption is made that the reference to a third party acquiring the right of inheritance does not turn this agreement into a contract made in favor of the third party. The paper focuses on the controversial issue of the limits of the discretion of the testator and the essential conditions of the inheritance contract. The author differntiates the gaps in the law in the regulation of a number of issues related to the conclusion and execution of an inheritance contract, some wordings of Art. 1118 and 1140.1 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation and suggests proposals that improve rules under consideration. The author comes to the conclusion that the legal structure of inheritance law raises many questions caused by faulty legal formulations and insufficient completeness of legal regulation, which can give rise not only to doctrinal discussions, but also to contradictory law enforcement practice.

1. Aleksikova OE, Melnik EA. Perspektivy razvitiya institutov nasledstvennogo dogovora i sovmestnogo zaveshchaniya suprugov v rossiyskom nasledstvennom prave [Prospects for the development of institutions of inheritance contract and joint will of spouses in Russian inheritance law]. Central Russian Journal of Social Sciences. 2017;12(1):231-236 (In Russ.).

2. Belootchenko EA. Nasledstvennyy dogovor v ramkakh reformirovaniya rossiyskogo nasledstvennogo prava [Inheritance Agreement within the Framework of Reforming Russian Inheritance Law]. Leningrad Legal Journal. 2017;2(48):122-130 (In Russ.).

3. Blinkov OE. O nasledstvennom dogovore v rossiyskom nasledstvennom prave: byt ili ne byt? [On the Hereditary Contract in the Russian Inheritance Law: To Be Or Not to Be?]. Inheritance Law. 2015;4:3-5 (In Russ.).

4. Grebenkina IA. Sovershenstvovanie nasledstvennogo prava: vse li predlagaemye izmeneniya obosnovanny? [Improvement of Inheritance Law: Are All the Proposed Changes Justified?]. Lexrussica. 2016;11(120):135-142 (In Russ.).

5. Karapetov AG, editor. Dogovornoe i obyazatelstvennoe pravo (obshchaya chast): postateynyy kommentariy k statyam 307-453 Grazhdanskogo Kodeksa Rossiyskoy Federatsii [Contractual and obligation law (general part): article-by-article commentary to articles 307-453 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation]. Moscow: Statut Publ.; 2017 (In Russ.).

6. Dolinskaya VV. o tendentsiyakh razvitiya i problemakh nasledstvennogo prava Rossii [On Evolution Trends and Inheritance Law Problems in Russia]. Laws of Russia: Experience, Analysis, Practice. 2018;10:3-13 (In Russ.).

7. Makovsky AL. Kak luchshe garantirovat nasledovanie. Normy nasledstvennogo prava v proekte tretey chasti Grazhdanskogo kodeksa Rossiyskoy Federatsii [The Best way to guarantee inheritance. Provisions of inheritance law in the draft of the third part of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation]. Legislation and Economics. 1997;3-4:37-41 (In Russ.).

8. Matveev IV. Nasledstvennyy dogovor: zarubezhnyy opyt i perspektivy poyavleniya v grazhdanskom prave Rossiyskoy Federatsii [Hereditary Contract: International Experience and Prospects of the Emergence of the Civil Law of the Russian Federation]. Russian Justice. 2015;1:6-9 (In Russ.).

9. Mikhailova IA. Uslovnye zaveshchaniya: Istoriya i sovremennosti [Contingent Wills: A Historic Overview]. Juridical Journal of Samara University. 2016;2(1):37-45 (In Russ.).

10. Mikhailova IA. Nasledstvennyy dogovor: dostoinstva i nedostatki [An Inheritance Agreement: Advantages and Disadvantages]. Inheritance Law. 2018;4:31-37 (In Russ.).

11. Petrov EYu, editor. Nasledstvennoe pravo: postateynyy kommentariy k statyam 1110-1185, 1224 Grazhdanskogo Kodeksa Rossiyskoy Federatsii [Inheritance law: article-by-article commentary to articles 11101185, 1224 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation]. Moscow: M-Logos Publ.; 2018 (In Russ.).

12. Novikov AA. K istorii zaveshchaniya pod usloviem v otechestvennom grazhdanskom prave [On the history of the will in the context of domestic civil law]. In: Hakselberg BL, Tuzova DO, editors. Civil Law Studies. Issue 1: Collection of research papers in memory of Professor I. V. Fedorov. Moscow: Statut Publ.; 2004 (In Russ.).

13. Papushchina NYu. Nasledstvennyy dogovor: perspektiva poyavleniya v rossiyskom nasledstvennom prave [How the Future May Unfold Inherited Contract in Inheritance Law of Russian Federation]. Notarial Bulletin. 2016;3:15-20 (In Russ.).

14. Sviridova EA. Problemnye aspekty nedeystvitelnosti zaveshchaniy v rossiyskom i belorusskom zakonodatelstve [Problematic Aspects of Invalidity of Wills in Russian and Belarusian Legislation]. Young Scientist. 2015;24(204):173-176 (In Russ.).

15. Expert opinion dated February 8, 2016, No. 149-1 / 2016 on the draft federal law No. 801269-6 "On amendments to parts one, two and three of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation, as well as to certain legislative acts of the Russian Federation" ( in terms of improving inheritance law). " In: Expert opinions of the Council under the President of the Russian Federation on the codification and improvement of civil legislation in 2016: Proceedings of the 6th International Scientific and Practical Conference "Civil Law of Russia. Results of the Year." [January 25, 2017]. Moscow: Statute Publ.; 2017 (In Russ.).