Compensation for the Loss of Ability to Labor and other Gainful Activities as an Alternative to Loss of Earnings (Income) Compensation for the Victim in Tort Obligations

The paper is devoted to the problem of determining compensation for the loss of the ability to labor and other gainful activities as an alternative to loss of earnings (income) compensation. The author draws attention to the legal and doctrinal conditions that ensure the recognition of the ability to gainful work as an independent property of the victim’s personality subject to economic assessment regardless of the actual decrease in the victim’s financial well-being. The paper highlights that the speculative nature of the claim of this kind is greatly exaggerated, since only the indicator of depreciation of the ability to gainful work in various forms has the property of uncertainty, and it is necessary to refer to the category of expected earnings (income) only when it is evaluated as a monetary equivalent. Based on the interpretation of the principles of reasonableness and feasibility, the the author concludes that it is critically important to use traditional calculation parameters (the degree of disability and estimated income) that allow providing an economic assessment of the totality of the lost professionally significant qualities of the victim that he could use in the field of gainful employment in different periods of life in the absence of an event of a wrongful act. The paper justifies that, with respect to certain categories of victims (minors, individual entrepreneurs, etc.), the necessary degree of reliability of such parameters can be achieved by referring to official statistical information or summary indicators prepared on its basis (average age of commencement of employment, indicators of profitability of certain types of economic activity, etc.). 

1. Agarkov MM. Obligations from causing harm (current law and tasks of the Civil Code of the USSR). Problemy sotsialisticheskogo prava. 1939;1:55-74. (In Russ.).

2. Bakunin SN. Compensation for harm caused to the life and health of a minor: social and legal aspects. Civilist. 2007;2:65-67. (In Russ.).

3. Bogdanov DE. The triune essence of justice in the field of tort liability. Journal of Russian Law. 2013;7:49-62. (In Russ.).

4. Boldyrev VA. Legal problems of compensation of earnings (income) lost as a result of damage to health. Obshhestvo i pravo. 2003;2:198-212. (In Russ.).

5. Chulyukova SA. The amount of compensation for damage caused to the life of a citizen. Pravo i gosudarstvo: teoriya i praktika. 2020;7(187):15-18. (In Russ.).

6. Dorey DL, Rentiers BL. The calculation of damages for bodily injury claims. Vancouver: Dolden Wallace Folick LLP; 2014.

7. Gutsalyuk DA, Trofimova MS. About some features of practical application of regulations Part 2 Clause 1085 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation. Beneficium. 2019;3(32):67-76. (In Russ.).

8. Haskelberg BL. Some issues of compensation for damage caused to the health of citizens in the performance of work duties. Topical issues of state and law at the present stage: Collection of articles. Tomsk; 1982. (In Russ.).

9. Husaini MF, Kamaliah S. An Analysis of Inconsistent Methodology to Compute Permanent Future Nursing Care Costs in Personal Injury Claim. Pertanika Journal of Social Sciences and Humanities. 2021;29(2):1-16.

10. Malein NS. Compensation for damage caused to the individual. Moscow: Yuridicheskaya literatura Publ.; 1965. (In Russ.).

11. Wand K, Mendelson D. An overview of liability and compensation for personal injury in China under the General Principles of Civil Law. Torts Law Journal. 1996;4:137-172.

12. Zhaglina ME, Zhaglin AV. Civil liability for causing harm to the health of minors (based on the materials of judicial practice). Zakony Rossii: opyt, analiz, praktika [Laws of Russia: experience, analysis, practice]. 2022;4:3035. (In Russ.).