Consent of a Person to a Criminal Case (Criminal Prosecution) Dismissal for Reasons other than Exoneration: Definition and Content

A criminal case (prosecution) dismissal for reasons other than exoneration is associated with the onset of various negative consequences for a person. These may include confiscation of property belonging to them and recognized as material evidence; filing a civil claim against them for compensation for damage caused by a person subjected to criminal prosecution; recovery of procedural costs. The need to clarify consent to a criminal case (prosecution) dismissal is a guarantee of the rights to judicial protection and access to justice, and it is attributable to the need to inform the person about the negative consequences accompanying the criminal case (prosecution) dismissal. The obligation to clarify the consequences of the termination of the case should be reflected in the law. At the same time, in pre-trial proceedings, effective judicial control should act as a reliable guarantee of the property right of the person against whom the criminal case is terminated, assuming the court’s authority to independently make decisions on issues related to the termination of the criminal case (including those related to reimbursement of procedural costs and resolution of the fate of material evidence). The thesis of the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation on the equivalence of disagreement with the seizure of property following the termination of a criminal case with disagreement with such termination in general is critically evaluated. The optimal approach seems to be in which the consent of a person to a criminal case (prosecution) dismissal is clarified after a certified written explanation of the negative legal consequences of a non-rehabilitating decision. This, however, does not exclude the possibility of appealing the decision in its part, which does not relate to the cancellation of a criminal case (prosecution) dismissal as a whole.

1. Filimonov SA. Termination of a criminal case and criminal prosecution for reasons other than exoneration: Theoretical and practical aspects. The author’s abstract of the Cand. Diss. (Law). Krasnodar; 2009. (In Russ.).

2. Mazyuk RV. How to recover procedural costs upon a criminal case dismissal with the imposition of a court fine. Ugolovnyy protsess [Criminal Procedure]. 2017;11:74-78. (In Russ.).

3. Nasonov AA. Consent as a necessary condition for a criminal case dismissal for reasons other than exoneration. Vestnik Volgogradskoy akademii MVD Rossii [Volgograd Academy of the Russian Internal Affairs Ministry’s Digest]. 2023;1(64):51-56. (In Russ.).

4. Savchenko AN. The possibility of collecting court costs in case of termination of the case for reconciliation of the parties. Ugolovnyy protsess [Criminal Procedure]. 2014;4:38-42. (In Russ.).

5. Sinelnikova VS. Recovery of procedural costs upon criminal prosecution dismissal for reasons other than exoneration by the court of first instance: Need for modern realities. Zakon i pravo [Law and Legislation]. 2020;8:113-116. (In Russ.).

6. Skoblikov PA. Resolution of the Plenum of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation on confiscation of property: Critical analysis. Zakon. 2018;9:122-132. (In Russ.).

7. Trubnikova TV. Is recognition as physical evidence a new type of coercive measure? (Based on the materials of the study of the problems of abuse of law in criminal proceedings). Zakony Rossii: opyt, analiz, praktika [Russian Laws: Experience, Analysis, Practice]. 2018;5:49-55. (In Russ.).

8. Zelenin SR. On the recovery of procedural costs upon termination of a criminal case for reasons other than exoneration. Izvestiya Tulskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. Ekonomicheskie i yuridicheskie nauki [Proceedings of the TSU. Economic and Legal Sciences]. 2013;2(2):74-87. (In Russ.).